Home / Message templates / Keep in Touch Email to a Candidate
Keep-in-Touch Emails for Candidates You Want to Hire Later
A keep-in-touch email to a candidate is a short, personal note with a real reason behind it. That reason might be a market update, a fitting role, news in their field or a check on their new job. It never just says hello. The one principle is to give before you ask. Candidates you did not place stay warm when each email makes them a little better off.
The candidate who came in second is often your next placement. They interviewed well. The client liked them. The timing was wrong by one seat. If you vanish after the no, someone else fills that seat next time. If you stay in touch, you are the first call they make.
The emails that land are small and specific. They remember what the candidate said they wanted. They offer something useful without a hook. And they are spaced so the candidate is glad to see your name, not tired of it.
On this page
Write yours in 20 seconds
Free, no signup. The example is filled in: press the button, then replace it with your own situation. In Capstone, a message like it is written for each person you know when their check-in is due.
11 examples to copy
One message is easy. Hundreds of people, all year, is the hard part. Capstone Outreach puts everyone you know on a rhythm you pick, from weekly to every three months. When someone is due, a message like these is already written in your voice from your history with them. You approve it, and it goes from your own email or phone. See the CRM for recruiters.
Start 14 days free, then $25/mo
Everyone on a rhythm. Who is due, and when. Recorded in the app on a demo account.
1. Two days after the no, with real feedback
Subject: Feedback from [Company], and a request
Why it works: Specific feedback after a no is rare. Asking what they want next turns a rejection into a file you can act on.
2. Silver medalist, the same role reopened
Subject: The [Company] role is open again
Why it works: Being asked for by name is the best news a silver medalist can get, and skipping the early rounds makes yes easy.
3. Silver medalist, a near-identical role elsewhere
Subject: The role you should have gotten, at a different company
Why it works: Reminding them of your promise, then keeping it, is the whole reason to stay in touch with candidates you didn't place.
4. Market update, no role attached
Subject: What I'm seeing in [function] hiring
Why it works: Candidates stay engaged with a recruiter who gives them intelligence they can use in their own negotiations.
5. They took a job elsewhere
Subject: Congratulations on [new company]
Why it works: Celebrating a win you did not make tells the candidate your interest in them is not just about a fee.
6. Six months into their new job
Subject: Six months in: how's it going?
Why it works: Six months is when the shine wears off. A quiet check-in puts you first in line the day they look again.
7. Sharing something tied to what they told you
Subject: Thought of you: [topic]
Why it works: Remembering a goal they mentioned months ago is the clearest proof you were actually listening.
8. Asking for a referral, after giving first
Subject: Do you know someone for [scope]?
Why it works: Candidates refer freely when you have given first, and the soft invitation lets them raise their own hand.
9. They got promoted
Subject: Congratulations on the promotion
Why it works: Noticing a promotion and updating your view of them shows you track their career, not just their availability.
10. After a year of silence, honest re-introduction
Subject: It's been a year
Why it works: Owning the gap and asking only for ten minutes resets the relationship without pretending the silence didn't happen.
11. Updating what would make them move
Subject: One question to keep your file current
Why it works: A short, honest request for their current criteria keeps your outreach relevant and shows you won't spam them.
Sending these to more than a few people? See how people keep track of who to follow up with, and when: what a personal CRM does and the best personal CRMs, compared.
When to send it
- Send a real-feedback note within two business days of a rejection, while the process is fresh.
- Check in again at about six to eight weeks, with something useful and no role attached.
- Then write every three to four months. Tie each note to a reason: a promotion, a fitting role, or news in their field.
- Reach out right away when the client reopens the role or a near-identical one appears.
- Mark the anniversary of their new job if they took one elsewhere. It is a natural, low-pressure touch.
Subject lines
- Feedback from [Company], and a request
- The [Company] role is open again
- What I'm seeing in [function] hiring
- Congratulations on [new company]
- Six months in: how's it going?
- Thought of you: [topic]
- Do you know someone for [scope]?
- Congratulations on the promotion
- It's been a year
- One question to keep your file current
- No role, just a note
- The seat I promised to call you about
- [Hiring manager] asked about you
- Still thinking about our conversation in [month]
What to avoid
- Don't disappear after the rejection. That is the moment the candidate decides if you were worth their time.
- Don't send an email with nothing in it. A note that only checks in teaches them to skip your name.
- Don't pitch a role that ignores what they told you they wanted. It proves you did not listen.
- Don't write more than once a quarter without a reason. Frequency without value feels like pressure.
- Don't forget to update your notes. Sending a mid-level role to someone just promoted ends the relationship.
After you send it
If a keep-in-touch note gets no reply, let it sit. It was a gift, not a question. Write again in three to four months with a new reason. If a role-specific email gets no reply, send one short follow-up after a week, then stop pitching. Log everything they tell you: what they want, when they might look, how they prefer to hear from you. The file you build between searches is what makes the next search fast.
Building the habit: how to keep in touch with contacts and what a personal CRM does.
Sending this to a whole list? Capstone Outreach remembers everyone you send it to. When it's time to check in again, the next message is already written in your voice. You approve each one, and it goes from your own email or phone.
Start 14 days free, then $25/mo
A study of 20 million LinkedIn members found that acquaintances, more than close friends, led to new jobs (Science, 2022). Capstone keeps those people warm. You approve every message, and it goes from your own email or phone.
Frequently asked questions
How do you keep in touch with candidates you didn't hire?
Send real feedback within two days, then a useful note every three to four months. Each email should carry something. Think of a market update, a fitting role, a resource tied to their goals, or a note on their news. Ask what they want next and write it down. Candidates stay warm when every email leaves them a little better off.
What is a silver medalist candidate and how should I treat them?
A silver medalist is the runner-up, the person who nearly got the offer. Treat them as a likely future placement. Give them specific feedback and ask what they'd want next time. Call them first when the role reopens or a similar one appears. Many of the best hires are silver medalists from a search six months earlier.
How often should a recruiter email a candidate they didn't place?
Every three to four months is a good rhythm, with a reason each time. Add an extra note when something real happens: a promotion, a fitting role, or a market shift. Fewer than twice a year and they forget you. More than once a month and they feel chased. Quality matters more than count.
What should I write to a candidate who took another job?
Congratulate them, with no pitch. Mention something they said they wanted and how the new role seems to deliver it. Say you will check in at six months. Then do it. A candidate who hears from you only when you need them will not take the call later. One who hears from you when they win will.
Should I ask candidates I didn't place for referrals?
Yes, once you have given something first. Feedback, a market update, or a useful introduction earns the right to ask. Keep the ask small: one name is plenty. Promise to keep the referral confidential. And leave room for them to raise their own hand, because sometimes the best referral is the person you asked.